Australia is a winning country, but it looks to me like Tony Abbott is a losing PM

  • Post

  • 1 March 2015

  • Posted by Alastair Campbell

  • 3

If Australians awake tomorrow to see a bleary-eyed me talking to them down a line from late evening London, apologies. In addition to trying to stick to a long-planned media and events book launch schedule, I have had to factor in Burnley FC and, less expectedly, hospital visits to a relative taken ill. So, barely a week in, I am feeling a bit knackered. However, resilience is one of the key themes of the book, WINNERS and how they succeed, so I will be there, promoting the book to one of my favourite countries. Indeed, the importance of resilience is one of the reasons I wrote a chapter called 'the winning spirit of Australia,' which produces a disproportionate number of winners for its relatively small population, several of whom I have been lucky enough to interview. Somehow though, I don't think we are going to be able to add the current PM to the list of famous Aussie winners, to join the likes of Whitlam, Hawke, Keating and Howard. Yes, he won an election. But political winners have to endure, and make real and lasting change, and I am not convinced Tony Abbott will do either. Unless something pretty drastic changes, he could well be out of a job within a few months. One of the central themes of the book is that winners know the difference between strategy and tactics, whether in sport, business or politics. Tony Abbott is failing because he has failed to have a clear strategy and has been tripped up by tactics. I write about the considerable differences that existed between Tony Blair and Gordon Brown, and suggest that if the New Labour team had hung together, we might still be there, not least because David Cameron is another who confuses tactics and strategy (maybe Aussie strategist Lynton Crosby, mastermind of the appalling Michael Howard 2005 election campaign in the UK, is the link here). Yet despite all the differences we won three successive elections because we had a shared purpose, a sense of direction: a strategy. In contrast Abbott seems from this distance to have come to power without a clear plan for government; without a clear strategy to unify his party and keep them marching on together towards shared, big goals. If you govern like this, plan-less and based on weekly opinion polls - especially in a political scene as poll-driven as Australia - the ability to lead will be judged on a weekly basis too, which at the moment seems to be calling for a change of government and a change of PM. By coincidence, as I write in the book, I was in Australia for a speech, and met former PM Julia Gillard on the day she was finally challenged to a vote which led to her ousting by Kevin Rudd. So I have seen close up how brutal Aussie politics can be. It is hard to see how Abbott avoids similar brutality coming his way. In so far as his problems have made UK headlines, they have come from the unusual G20 Summit greeting, when he told the world how well he was doing domestically, and especially from the truly bizarre decision to give a knighthood to the already honour-festooned the Duke of Edinburgh. In WINNERS there is a chapter on The Queen because despite being a Republican I do see her as a winner, not least because she has seen off Republicanism for another generation, and I honestly think she would have been surprised by Abbott’s decision. But of far greater significance than these tactical errors was his first  budget. Budgets are an opportunity to set direction - Gordon Brown was brilliant at this when Chancellor - yet Abbott's was full of contradictions. He was pretty effective in opposition when the pursuit of power often requires rapid rebuttal and good traditional comms built around clear key messages. When in power there are clear phases: a honeymoon period where you have the goodwill of victory putting wind in the sails of change; a corrective phase, where the task is already set but you are adapting to power; and the reform phase when you are trying to set out and implement the overall plan. All of Australia’s great leaders excelled at the last of these which is why it has always punched above its weight on the world stage; at the moment, politically, it still throws punches, but none of them seem to land. One of the reasons I have written this book, looking at winners in sport, business and politics, is that I believe all can learn from each other. Politicians and business pay lip service to sport - they like to be associated with it through sponsorship or by association. But when looking at all the key areas winners have to master - strategy, teamship, leadership, data and innovation, boldness, resilience, the ability to manage crisis, mindset and psychology - they can actually learn a lot from the best of sport. Launching the book in the UK last week I found myself constantly drawing on insights of some of the Aussies we spoke to for the book - Surfer Layne Beachley - one of the most remarkable people in the book. I have been telling everyone about her, and she shares a chapter on resilience with none other than Nelson Mandela. - Aussie Rules 'player of the century' Leigh Matthews - I could have talked to him for days. So many insights and so many stories, especially with regard to what he learned as a player that he took into management. - Rugby League star Johnathan Thurston - I loved the way he spoke of how he tried to bring on younger talent. - Nova Peris, the first Aboriginal Olympic gold medallist, and Federal MP - 'Whatever card you are dealt in life you just have to deal with it.' - Ric Charlesworth, who can speak from experience about performance and coaching, politics and sport, such a wealth of experience across so many sectors and a fantastic insight into teamship. - Cricketer Shane Warne, who told me this: - 'We have a lot of high achievers, and I think you can go right back to where we came from, how we started out as a country, all the slaves and the convicts, and the idea we were somebody else’s rejects. There are three things that are really Australian to me: we have the “never give up” attitude; we like being in the thick of it; and we’re not afraid to fail. Not being afraid to fail is a huge part of this. “Come on, mate, I’ll have a go,” and maybe it works and maybe it doesn’t, but you’ll never know until you try. Some countries don’t try things the same way we do because it’s hammered into them that they cannot fail. That’s a hopeless way to go about things to my mind. “Never give up” are the three most important words in the language.’ That to me is the Aussie mindset, and so many of my interviewees agreed it was the country's history, and in particular the relationship with England, that was responsible for it. It will be interesting to see how Tony Abbott fares in trying to apply it over the next few weeks and months. 'Never give up' is great in theory. Sometimes other factors and other people can overwhelm it.  

3 responses to “Australia is a winning country, but it looks to me like Tony Abbott is a losing PM”

  1. Loved my time in Oz a good few years ago. Wish I could visit it more, but it is bluddy the other side of the World, not exactly down the road.

    And I have noticed in recent weeks Ali, the stop-start Tory HQ political machine is all over the place for coming May 7. It is as if they just do not have any imagination, which is stating the bleeding obvious, I know.

  2. Enjoyed the interview on the ABC and looking forward to the book Alastair. Fascinating watching Abbott fight like a scrapyard dog to keep his job, those bloody Jesuits have a knack of breeding them tough.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

542. Starmer Loses His Defence Secretary: What Next?

What does John Healey's shock resignation mean for Keir Starmer, whose position is already on the line ahead of Andy Burnham's crunch by-election in Makerfield? Who might replace Healey in one of the ... Continue

11 June 2026

Post

Posted by Goalhanger

541. Trump’s World Cup Mess and Kushner’s Albania Deal

As the Trump administration blocks a referee from entering the US, is this the most political world cup of all time, and just how messy will it get? Can the Democrats flip the Senate, and would it act... Continue

11 June 2026

Post

Posted by Goalhanger

540. The Untold Iran Crisis, Henry Nowak, and Farage’s Politics of Rage

As Trump’s Iran disaster continues, are we facing a full-blown energy and economic crisis in the UK and beyond? Why are politicians refusing to be honest about the real cost of the Iran crisis? What... Continue

10 June 2026

Post

Posted by Goalhanger

192. Are We On The Brink Of World War III? (Odd Arne Westad)

How similar is today's world to the months before the outbreak of World War I? Could Taiwan, India-China tensions, or an unforeseen crisis be the spark that sets the world ablaze? Are our leaders too ... Continue

8 June 2026

Post

Posted by Goalhanger

539. Embezzlement, the Mandelson Texts, and Hasan Piker’s UK Ban

What does the SNP embezzlement case reveal about how scandal-ridden British politics is? Is the banning of prominent left-wing American commentators Hasan Piker and Cenk Uygur a sensible decision or a... Continue

4 June 2026

Post

Posted by Goalhanger

538. The Pope’s AI Warning and Alastair Reacts to Blair’s Attack

Is Pope Leo’s encyclical the most important contribution to the AI debate so far, and is he doing more to hold Silicon Valley to account than any Western government? What did Alastair say to Tony Bl... Continue

3 June 2026

Post

Posted by Goalhanger

191. Is It Already Too Late to Control AI? (Anthropic Co-Founder, Jack Clark)

Why is one of AI's most powerful insiders scared of what he's building? Who's really in charge of the technology reshaping our world? Is it too late for governments to regulate it? Rory and Matt Clif... Continue

1 June 2026

Post

Posted by Goalhanger

177. Olaf Scholz: Putin, Power, and Far-Right Populism

Does the former German Chancellor think that Germany was wrong to rely on Russian gas in the run up to the war in Ukraine? What does Olaf Scholz think is behind the rise of the far-right Alternative f... Continue

23 February 2026

Post

Posted by Goalhanger