166. John Swinney: An Independent Scotland Is An Open Scotland

  • Podcast

  • 15 December 2025

  • Posted by Alastair Campbell

  • 1

What is the future of the Scottish independence movement? How does the SNP rebuild trust and support for independence after a series of bruising scandals? Why did the Scottish First Minister feel disrespected by a series of Conservative Prime Ministers? 


Alastair and Rory are joined by Scottish First Minister John Swinney to answer all this and more. 


Gift The Rest Is Politics Plus this Christmas - give someone a whole year of Rory and Alastair’s miniseries, ad-free listening, early access to episodes and live show tickets, an exclusive members’ newsletter, discounted book prices, and a private chatroom on Discord. Just go to https://therestispolitics.supportingcast.fm/gifts


And of course, you can still join for yourself any time at ⁠therestispolitics.com


For Leading listeners, there’s free access to the Wordsmith Academy - plus their report on the future of legal skills. Visit https://www.wordsmith.ai/politics


Social Producer: Celine Charles

Video Editor: Josh Smith

Producer: Alice Horrell

Senior Producer: Nicole Maslen

Head of Politics: Tom Whiter

Exec Producers: Tony Pastor + Jack Davenport

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

One response to “166. John Swinney: An Independent Scotland Is An Open Scotland”

  1. It’s quite refreshing to listen to John Swinney in this setting where you can get a sense of humanity and he appeared quite candid. I think he did side swerve some points re education and health service. Many issues are still prevalent in Scotland with regards to the centralisation of maternity services and as a father of a primary school child I still need to be convinced of the SNPs education policy.

    On the whole, I thoroughly enjoyed this interview. John is well-read, and answered well and I also think you held him into account, not giving him an easy ride either.

    That is what needs to happen for Scottish people to be convinced that the SNP can still deliver for Scotland, and the overall independence question.

    I am an independence and SNP voter.

    PS. My mother’s family are from Crieff, Rory. I’m still scarred from childhood having to hike up the hill from the town back to my family friends house.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

539. Embezzlement, the Mandelson Texts, and Hasan Piker’s UK Ban

What does the SNP embezzlement case reveal about how scandal-ridden British politics is? Is the banning of prominent left-wing American commentators Hasan Piker and Cenk Uygur a sensible decision or a... Continue

4 June 2026

Post

Posted by Goalhanger

538. The Pope’s AI Warning and Alastair Reacts to Blair’s Attack

Is Pope Leo’s encyclical the most important contribution to the AI debate so far, and is he doing more to hold Silicon Valley to account than any Western government? What did Alastair say to Tony Bl... Continue

3 June 2026

Post

Posted by Goalhanger

191. Is It Already Too Late to Control AI? (Anthropic Co-Founder, Jack Clark)

Why is one of AI's most powerful insiders scared of what he's building? Who's really in charge of the technology reshaping our world? Is it too late for governments to regulate it? Rory and Matt Clif... Continue

1 June 2026

Post

Posted by Goalhanger

177. Olaf Scholz: Putin, Power, and Far-Right Populism

Does the former German Chancellor think that Germany was wrong to rely on Russian gas in the run up to the war in Ukraine? What does Olaf Scholz think is behind the rise of the far-right Alternative f... Continue

23 February 2026

Post

Posted by Goalhanger

Why Trump Wants Greenland

Why has Donald Trump considered invading Greenland? How does he think it will benefit him? What is the role of China in the Arctic? And what animals have Russia trained to spy for them? Listen as Alas... Continue

23 February 2026

Post

Posted by Goalhanger

503. Andrew’s Arrest: What Next?

Why has the disgraced Andrew Mountbatten Windsor been arrested? How damaging is this unprecedented moment for the royal family? How effective was King Charles’ response? Join Alastair and the forme... Continue

19 February 2026

Post

Posted by Goalhanger

502. How Nigel Farage Gets Away With It (Question Time)

Why is Reform UK's leader not being properly challenged by the press, and how does he get away with it? What does this reveal about the international populist playbook? How can our democracies be bett... Continue

19 February 2026

Post

Posted by Goalhanger

176. How Close Are We To War With Iran? (Robert Malley)

How does the former US Special Representative for Iran think US-Iranian relations will improve? Is there a method to Trump’s madness when it comes to foreign policy? Why does Robert believe the “t... Continue

16 February 2026

Post

Posted by Goalhanger